Skip to content
Home
>
DC
>
Senate Judiciary Chairman wants answers...

Senate Judiciary Chairman wants answers over Wingate’s alleged use of AI in order blocking anti-DEI law

By: Frank Corder - October 6, 2025

U.S. District Judge Henry Wingate smiles on Aug. 19, 2022, in Jackson, Miss. Wingate ruled Thursday, June 1, 2023, that the Mississippi chief justice cannot be a defendant in a lawsuit that challenges a state law dealing with appointed judges. (AP Photo/Rogelio V. Solis, File)

  • Senator Chuck Grassley called on the district judge to re-docket his original order to preserve a transparent history of the Court’s actions.

Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, a Republican from Iowa, has written to two federal judges regarding their alleged use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) to draft court orders with little to no human verification.

U.S. District Judge Henry Wingate’s order blocking Mississippi’s anti-DEI law is one of the matters Grassley is inquiring about from the judges.

As previously reported by Magnolia Tribune, Wingate’s July order temporarily blocked Mississippi’s anti-DEI law passed by the Legislature this year as part of a lawsuit filed by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Mississippi and the Mississippi Center for Justice in June.

The new law, as it was described by lawmakers, prevents public K-12 and higher education institutions from utilizing diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) practices when making decisions concerning school employment, academic opportunities, and student engagement. Such decisions are to be based on an individual’s merit and qualifications rather than a person’s race, color, sexual orientation, or gender.  The law passed through both bodies in the State Capitol and then received the governor’s signature in April. 

After Wingate entered the order blocking the law from taking effect, both sides of the legal challenge noticed significant factual errors in the federal judge’s ruling. Two days later, Mississippi Attorney General’s office, defending the new law, in consultation with the plaintiffs, filed a motion to clarify or correct the Order Granting Temporary Restraining Order issued by Wingate.

Judge Wingate amended his original order the following day and then removed the initial ruling from docket, backdating the amended order as if it were the original ruling.

Senator Chuck Grassley (Photo from Senate Judiciary Committee website)

In a statement from Grassley’s office, the Senate said the oversight inquiry follows public reporting that Judge Wingate and U.S. District of New Jersey Judge Julien Xavier Neals both issued court orders containing serious factual inaccuracies, prompting allegations of AI use.

“As Chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, I am committed to safeguarding litigants’ rights and ensuring that every party in federal court receives fair treatment and careful review by the Article III judges confirmed by the Senate,” Grassley wrote. “No less than the attorneys who appear before them, judges must be held to the highest standards of integrity, candor, and factual accuracy. Indeed, Article III judges should be held to a higher standard, given the binding force of their rulings on the rights and obligations of litigants before them.”

Grassley is asking Wingate and Neals to explain whether they, their law clerks or any court staff used generative AI – or entered non-public case information into generative AI tools – in preparing their decisions.

Further, Grassley called on the district judges to re-docket their original orders to preserve a transparent history of the Courts’ actions.

Grassley’s letter to Wingate can be read in full below.

About the Author(s)
author profile image

Frank Corder

For nearly two decades, Frank Corder has reported and offered analysis on government, public policy, elections, business and matters of faith. He is the Editor for Magnolia Tribune where he oversees the day-to-day content development. Frank’s interviews, articles, and columns have been syndicated throughout Mississippi as well as in various national publications. His resume includes appearances on the BBC, CBS News, ABC News, and Fox News, among others. Frank is a frequent analyst on radio and television, providing insight and commentary on the inner workings of the Magnolia State and beyond. During his career, Frank has interviewed government officials and candidates from City Halls to the White House, including Presidential candidates, White House officials, U.S. Senators, Congressmen, Cabinet Secretaries, and Governors. He previously hosted his own local radio and television programs and has managed private businesses in the financial, hospitality, and retail sectors. Frank has served his community as an elected City Councilman and as an Assistant/Acting City Manager. In the wake of Hurricane Katrina, he led the effort to plan Pascagoula's recovery and rebuilding which earned him recognition as Mississippi's Volunteer of the Year. Frank also led Pascagoula's municipal government out of a $14.5 million deficit, which the Mississippi State Auditor heralded as a model for other communities facing dire financial straits. As the president of the Pascagoula High School Quarterback Club, Frank has self-published "The Book of Pascagoula Football." He has been married for over 25 years and has two children, both of whom work in public education. Email Frank: frank@magnoliatribune.com