Skip to content
Home
>
Elections
>
Fifth Circuit affirms decision striking...

Fifth Circuit affirms decision striking down Mississippi mail-in ballot law

By: Frank Corder - March 20, 2025

(Photo from Shutterstock)

  • Mississippi cannot count ballots that arrive after Election Day, the federal appeals court affirms, denying a petition for rehearing.

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has declined to rehear its previous ruling, maintaining its decision that Mississippi cannot count ballots that arrive after Election Day.

In October, a three-judge panel of the federal court sided with the Republican National Committee, the Mississippi Republican Party, the Mississippi Libertarian Party and two private individuals challenging the COVID-era state law which allowed for ballots to be received and counted up to five days after an election.

As previously reported, the plaintiffs sued Harrison County election officials, along with Mississippi Secretary of State Michael Watson, in their official capacities seeking an injunction against the 2020 mail-in ballot law based on the Election Law Clause of the U.S. Constitution. That clause gives Congress the authority to set the time for choosing the election of the president, senators, and members of the U.S. House of Representatives.

READ MORE: 5th Circuit sides with Republican Party, strikes down Mississippi mail-in ballot law

In their October ruling citing U.S. Supreme Court precedence, the three-judge panel held that while states are empowered by Congress to conduct federal elections, federal laws preempt state regulation of elections.

Last Friday, the court affirmed its decision, with ten judges voting to deny a rehearing and five voting in favor.

In writing for the majority, Judge Andrew Oldham noted, “The question presented to the panel was whether, in the absence of any federal statute authorizing any deviation from the uniform Election Day requirement, States nonetheless have freedom to accept ballots for as long as they would like. The panel held no.”

Writing in dissent, Judge James Graves Jr. disagreed with Oldham, stating, “Simply stated, federal law does not mandate that ballots be received by state officials before Election Day’s conclusion, and the panel’s contrary holding is erroneous.”

It is now up to the Mississippi Secretary of State and Attorney General’s offices to determine if the state will appeal the matter to the U.S. Supreme Court.

You can read the Fifth Circuit’s rehearing denial below.

About the Author(s)
author profile image

Frank Corder

For nearly two decades, Frank Corder has reported and offered analysis on government, public policy, elections, business and matters of faith. He is the Editor for Magnolia Tribune where he oversees the day-to-day content development. Frank’s interviews, articles, and columns have been syndicated throughout Mississippi as well as in various national publications. His resume includes appearances on the BBC, CBS News, ABC News, and Fox News, among others. Frank is a frequent analyst on radio and television, providing insight and commentary on the inner workings of the Magnolia State and beyond. During his career, Frank has interviewed government officials and candidates from City Halls to the White House, including Presidential candidates, White House officials, U.S. Senators, Congressmen, Cabinet Secretaries, and Governors. He previously hosted his own local radio and television programs and has managed private businesses in the financial, hospitality, and retail sectors. Frank has served his community as an elected City Councilman and as an Assistant/Acting City Manager. In the wake of Hurricane Katrina, he led the effort to plan Pascagoula's recovery and rebuilding which earned him recognition as Mississippi's Volunteer of the Year. Frank also led Pascagoula's municipal government out of a $14.5 million deficit, which the Mississippi State Auditor heralded as a model for other communities facing dire financial straits. As the president of the Pascagoula High School Quarterback Club, Frank has self-published "The Book of Pascagoula Football." He has been married for over 25 years and has two children, both of whom work in public education. Email Frank: frank@magnoliatribune.com